Early Holiday Ads Are Outrunning the Shopper

Quiet shopping street at dusk with glowing billboards and distant blurred figures

Early holiday ads are outrunning the shopper: WeRSM, citing Adweek on Nielsen, reported six times more holiday advertising in September than five years earlier, and 11% more than in 2025, while transaction data did not show widespread earlier buying. WeRSM’s conclusion for retailers is direct: an earlier media schedule is not an earlier customer journey.

Updated November 17, 2026

Key Takeaways

  • September holiday ads were six times the volume of five years earlier.
  • Retailers were nearly 64% of October holiday ads versus 45% of five-year holiday ad spend.
  • Cosmetics holiday CTV ads delivered 3.2 times the lift of non-holiday spots.
  • Transaction data did not show shoppers broadly buying earlier this year.

Are early holiday ads pulling demand forward?

Ad volume moved forward. Widespread earlier buying did not show up in the transaction data. Retailers accounted for nearly 64% of holiday ads in October, despite representing 45% of total holiday ad spend over the previous five years. In our reading, that share is a bid to be heard before competitors and budgets get louder, not a new purchase calendar.

Marketplace caught the same creep on the floor. Mari Shor, a retail analyst at Columbia Threadneedle Investments, said a weekend of errands looked like Christmas week, and that it was hard to know what was driving the crowds. Sheraz Mian, director of research at Zacks, said the season cannot be fully assessed until January.

“Because the business over the holiday period can be so lumpy, a lot of companies have tried to pull forward holiday promotions,” Shor told Marketplace.

Where do early holiday ads still earn their keep?

Nielsen’s historical sales-lift studies found that holiday ads on connected TV generally outperform non-holiday advertising. Cosmetics holiday spots delivered a 3.2-times greater sales lift than non-holiday spots. Retail and restaurant holiday ads delivered a 2.4-times greater lift. WeRSM’s read: results are not uniform, and an early start still depends on gift-giving fit and a reason to act.

Signal Figure What it measures
September holiday ads vs. five years earlier 6 times Ad volume, not sales
September volume vs. 2025 11% higher Year-over-year ad volume
Retailer share of October holiday ads Nearly 64% 45% of total holiday ad spend over five years
Cosmetics holiday CTV lift vs. non-holiday 3.2 times Nielsen historical sales-lift studies
Retail and restaurant holiday lift 2.4 times Nielsen historical sales-lift studies
NRF holiday retail sales forecast 4.2% growth Year-over-year sales, not ad return

Mark Mathews, chief economist at the National Retail Federation, described “cautious optimism” to Marketplace. Economists estimate the last inflation reading was around 4%, which Marketplace said leaves expected real sales at a slight bump against the NRF’s 4.2% forecast. In our analysis, a nominal figure near inflation is not a reason to front-load creative before the offer is ready.

What should brands balance before Black Friday week?

The reports do not point the same way.

  • Attention versus action. September volume is up sharply. Transaction data did not show widespread earlier shopping.
  • Deals versus caution. Consumers are hunting harder for discounts, Marketplace reported. Mathews said the consumer is concerned about gas prices and the economy and is going to be very, very careful.
  • Category fit. Connected TV holiday ads outperformed in cosmetics, retail, and restaurants. That is not a September start date for every product.
  • Walmart’s discounts. If Walmart is running more discounts, Mian said, that makes life problematic for other retailers targeting the same consumer base.

“It just flashed across my screen that they were on sale,” Mathews told Marketplace, about shoes from a brand his wife likes. A September ad can establish memory, WeRSM noted, and it can become background noise if the offer cannot hold attention until people are ready.

Our analysis: separate memory-building from the conversion ask. An earlier media schedule is not an earlier customer journey. Promotions pulled forward to smooth a lumpy season should not become the only message a careful shopper hears for weeks. A Black Friday media reset still has to sit on that gap.

How careful is demand before Black Friday week?

Mathews told Marketplace: “Recognition that the consumer is concerned about gas prices and the economy and is going to be very, very careful.” If Walmart is worried about the holidays, Marketplace reported, other retailers should be worried too.

Marketplace also said the deals probably are not going anywhere. In our analysis, that undercuts the fear of missing September without turning early ad volume into earlier demand.

Frequently asked questions

Are shoppers actually buying earlier this holiday season?

Transaction data did not show widespread evidence that consumers began shopping earlier, WeRSM reported. Marketplace also reported that most shoppers had not started yet.

How much has holiday advertising moved forward?

Nielsen saw six times more holiday advertising in September than five years earlier, and September volume was 11% higher than in 2025, WeRSM reported via Adweek.

Do holiday ads on connected TV outperform regular ads?

Nielsen’s historical sales-lift studies found holiday ads on connected TV generally outperform non-holiday ads, including a 3.2-times greater lift for cosmetics and a 2.4-times greater lift for retail and restaurants.

What holiday sales growth is forecast versus inflation?

The National Retail Federation forecasts holiday retail sales will grow 4.2% year over year. Marketplace said inflation around 4% leaves expected real sales at a slight bump.

Notice an error?

Help us improve our content by reporting any issues you find.